When considering home improvement projects that add charm and elegance, beadboard and shiplap often come up as popular choices for wall paneling. Both styles offer a distinctive aesthetic, but homeowners frequently ask: Beadboard vs. Shiplap: Which is more affordable? In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the differences, costs, and benefits of each option to help you make an informed decision.

What is Beadboard?

Beadboard is a type of wall paneling made from narrow vertical planks with a small ridge, or “bead,” between each plank. It is often used for wainscoting and adding texture to walls in kitchens, bathrooms, and even ceilings. Beadboard is available in various materials, from traditional wood to MDF (Medium Density Fiberboard) and vinyl.

Benefits of Beadboard

• Classic Aesthetic: Beadboard’s traditional style adds a quaint and cozy feel to any room. It’s commonly used in cottage, coastal, and farmhouse designs.
• Versatility: It can be applied to walls, ceilings, and even kitchen islands.
• Customizable: Beadboard can be painted in any color, making it easy to match your room’s decor.

What is Shiplap?

Shiplap refers to wooden boards with a rabbet or notch cut into the top and bottom, allowing the boards to overlap slightly when installed. Shiplap was traditionally used for barns and sheds but has surged in popularity for interior walls thanks to its rustic, clean-lined look. Like beadboard, shiplap is available in various materials including wood, MDF, and vinyl.

Benefits of Shiplap

• Modern Appeal: Shiplap gives a sleek and modern look, popularized by modern farmhouse decor trends.
• Easy Installation: The notched design of shiplap makes it easy to install, even for DIYers.
• Durability: Shiplap can be more durable than beadboard, depending on the material used, making it ideal for areas that may see more wear and tear, like hallways and mudrooms.

Beadboard vs. Shiplap: A Comparison of Costs

When deciding between beadboard and shiplap, affordability is a major concern for homeowners. Here’s a detailed look at how the two options compare in terms of price.

Material Costs

• Beadboard: The price of beadboard can range from $1 to $5 per square foot, depending on the material. MDF beadboard is generally cheaper, while solid wood options can be more expensive. On average, a typical room installation might cost around $700 to $1,000.
• Shiplap: Shiplap costs around $2 to $7 per square foot. Like beadboard, the price depends on the material used. Solid wood shiplap panels are pricier, while MDF and vinyl options are more affordable. A typical installation in a room can range from $1,000 to $1,500.

Installation Costs

• Beadboard: Professional installation of beadboard can add $1 to $2 per square foot to the total cost. DIY installation is possible for those with some experience, and pre-made panels can make the process easier.
• Shiplap: Installing shiplap costs around $2 to $3 per square foot if done by professionals. DIYers may find shiplap easier to install due to its notched design, which allows the boards to fit together snugly.

Which Is More Affordable Overall?

Beadboard vs. Shiplap: When it comes to overall affordability, beadboard tends to be the less expensive option, especially if you choose MDF or vinyl. Shiplap, while slightly more costly, can add a modern, sleek look that may increase your home’s resale value. Here’s a summary of the cost differences:

Material	Cost per sq. ft. (Material)	Cost per sq. ft. (Installed)
Beadboard	$1 – $5	$2 – $7
Shiplap	$2 – $7	$4 – $10

Style and Aesthetic Considerations

Choosing between beadboard and shiplap is not only about cost. You also need to consider the style and look you want for your space.

Beadboard Aesthetic

Beadboard adds a timeless, classic feel that works well in vintage, cottage, or coastal designs. It’s perfect for smaller spaces like bathrooms or for adding a charming wainscot along a hallway.

Shiplap Aesthetic

Shiplap is more versatile and can fit into both rustic and modern decor. It works exceptionally well in large open spaces, lending a sleek yet rustic look to living rooms, bedrooms, and kitchens.

Durability: Beadboard vs. Shiplap

Beadboard Durability

Beadboard made from solid wood is more durable than MDF or vinyl, though it’s not as resistant to moisture as shiplap. This makes it better suited for dry areas of the home like hallways and living rooms.

Shiplap Durability

Shiplap, particularly when made from solid wood or durable MDF, holds up well in high-traffic areas. Its overlapping design creates a tight seal, making it more resistant to moisture and humidity, which is beneficial in kitchens and bathrooms.

Installation: DIY or Hire a Pro?

Beadboard Installation

Beadboard can be a DIY-friendly project, especially if you use larger pre-made panels. These panels are easier to install but still require precise measurement and cutting. For the less experienced, hiring a professional ensures proper installation, particularly for ceiling applications.

Shiplap Installation

Shiplap’s notched boards make it a popular DIY choice. The boards interlock, making them easier to align, even for beginners. However, as with beadboard, professional installation can save time and ensure a perfect finish.

Beadboard vs. Shiplap: Which Should You Choose?

When weighing Beadboard vs. Shiplap, affordability is just one of many factors to consider. Beadboard is typically more affordable upfront, but shiplap may offer better long-term value due to its modern aesthetic and durability. Here’s a quick recap to help you decide:

• Choose Beadboard if: You’re looking for a classic, cozy feel, want to keep costs low, and are updating a small space like a bathroom or hallway.
• Choose Shiplap if: You prefer a sleek, modern look, have a larger budget, and need something durable for high-traffic areas like kitchens or living rooms.

FAQs

By evaluating Beadboard vs. Shiplap based on cost, durability, and style, you can choose the best option for your home improvement project.